Locations:
August 4, 2017/Opinion

Eric Kodish, M.D. at HuffPost: The Tragedy of Playing Politics with Children’s Health

Charlie Gard's life and tragic death co-opted by politics, ideologies

Media Contact

Cleveland Clinic News Service | 216.444.0141

We’re available to shoot custom interviews & b-roll for media outlets upon request.

Media Downloads

CCNS health and medical content is consumer-friendly, professional broadcast quality (available in HD), and available to media outlets each day.

Protesting

The case of Charlie Gard, a terminally ill British 11-month-old who passed away July 28, is deeply tragic for all involved: the parents who must try to come to terms with the fact that no curative therapy existed for their child; the physicians and nurses who have dedicated their lives to helping children and must continue to do what they think is best for the patient; and the judges who use phrases such as “heaviest of hearts” when handing down their judgments.

Cleveland Clinic bioethicist Eric Kodish, M.D., writes — with co-author Johan Bester, Ph.D., M.Phil., director of bioethics at the UNLV School of Medicine — that the tragedy is compounded when such cases become politicized, as has happened with Charlie, who was born with encephalomyopathic mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome (MDDS), a rare genetic illness.

Politicizing Charlie means that suddenly his case ceases to be about the suffering of a boy and his parents; it has been co-opted for a political and ideological purposes, complete with a set of villains who are ready to withhold from a child and parents what are rightly theirs. It uses the emotion around the case to galvanize people towards a specific political goal. It now becomes about us against them. The facts of the case and the suffering caused is now almost incidental to what has become a political phenomenon.

Read the entire piece at HuffPost. The Tragedy of Playing Politics with Children’s Health

Latest from the Newsroom

Shaker Heights Volleyball Standout Gabby Green to Receive Jim Donovan Courage Award

Shaker Heights Volleyball Standout Gabby Green to Receive Jim Donovan Courage Award

Examples of Cleveland Clinic’s $1.59 billion in community impact, including research, training and community health efforts.

Cleveland Clinic Invests $1.59 Billion in 2025 to Improve Community Health and Expand Access to Care

Photo of scale wit a tape measure.

Cleveland Clinic Study Identifies Best Treatment Strategies for Weight Loss After Stopping GLP-1 Drugs

Cleveland Clinic's new teaching kitchen and food pantry at the Langston Hughes Community Health & Education Center

Cleveland Clinic Opens Teaching Kitchen and Food Pantry on Cleveland's East Side

VeloSano riders

$20.2 Million Raised for VeloSano, Funding Cancer Research at Cleveland Clinic in 2026

Photo of spine imaging.

Cleveland Clinic Expands Orthopaedic Care in the Mahoning Valley Through Acquisition of Youngstown Orthopaedic Associates Practice

Lobby of new Toronto location

Cleveland Clinic Canada Moves to New Downtown Toronto Location

Artist's rendering of gene therapy for high triglycerides.

Gene Editing Therapy Trial Dramatically Lowers Dangerous Blood Fat Levels